In another, more blog-pertinent way, winter had arrived months ago. I am, of course, referring to Christmas Creep (a term I borrow from Gregg Easterbrook's excellent sports and other stuff column). Christmas, the attendant fake snow and ominous soundtrack, is back with us, muscling its way past Halloween (which I always thought should occupy larger commercial space than it does) and pushing Thanksgiving's nose into the dust (the last Thanksgiving decoration I can remember was one I colored in 5th grade art class, little did I know that poor purple and brown bird would become a memento of a lost age).
Not to be outdone, this is the summer creep edition of NextHaven. I will be reviewing two outdoor seafood restaurants that won't be serving you again until May, or according to the revised creep calendar, next Christmas Eve.
The first is the Lobster Shack in Branford. If you have never been to Branford, imagine it as the clean cut little sibling of New Haven, complete with its own green and original site of Yale University. It is tucked away just a few blocks from the green, although you would not be able to tell this as it is on a branch of the Branford Harbor, a body of water not visible from center Branford. Instead of theme appropriate decor, (say, a painting of a lobster) there are actual fishing boats in the harbor and steaming pots feet away from the seating. The downside of this exposure to feeling close to the food you consume (I don't know if the docked boats actually hauled the lobsters that went into my lobster rolls) is total exposure to the elements. All the seating is outdoors, which meant trying to huddle around my steamed clams for warmth. (I imagine being seated outdoors is pleasurable to some people, at some time, although I get cranky when I sit outdoors. The sun is either feeble or tyrranical, the breeze, blinding or sullen.
(Reading digression- As for reading recommendations, I suggest that before you consume your next buttery lobster roll, you read David Foster Wallace's essay "Consider the Lobster". It was initially published in the now defunct Gourmet magazine, but you can read it in his essay collection Consider the Lobster. While Wallace won't tell you what to do w/r/t eating lobster, he does make a convincing case that boiling a creature that is sensible to changes in temperature of several degrees, must be an extreme form of torture that no amount of buttery goodness can mask. I had not eaten lobster for about a decade, but thought that I could not forgo such a distinctly New England dish. Wallace makes a point of noting how easy it is to shrug off moral qualms for the sake of good food. In a later article I would like to write about the possibility of eating well and without shrugs in New Haven. Stay tuned.)
The second fish food place I visited is also outdoors. It is called, appropriately enough, The Place. ( I think that giving fish shacks more sophisticated names would betray something essential to the fabric of the restaurant's genre.) Although both provide excellent food and are staffed by some of the friendliest people I've ever met in this state (The owners of the Place hang out at the restaurant and man the grill and will relate the history of the restaurant to you; the Lobster Shack seems to be more of a family operation, but the members of the family operate more felicitously in their two trailers filled with boiling pots and surrounded by customers than most families can manage over Thanksgiving), The Place has several advantages over The Lobster Shack. Although they are both outdoors, the former is surrounded by trees and has a canopy, which pacifies even a weather infant like myself. The menu is slightly larger, with about a dozen offering as opposed to about 5, so if you don't feel like lobster (which The Place doesn't have anyway) you could have grilled catfish, or a grilled steak, or grilled corn. Also, there is a lot of grilling going on with several attendants including the owner grappling with what seem to be perilous flames, which makes for a striking background to your meal. The rules are extremely lax in The Place: 1. Throw your clam shells on the ground.
2. Bring food that they do not sell but you think might go well with your grilled blackfish.
3. Bring your own alcohol. (I always feel cultured unwrapping a chilled bottle of wine at a restaurant.)
These rules are the perfect recipe for extended hanging out and feeling some control over the experience you have.
As for the actual food, I feel like it would be a disservice to actually work through describing the food here. You will have to trust me that it is all sufficiently delicious. These places are conscious of being fine, but not elaborate.
(Reading digression- As for reading recommendations, I suggest that before you consume your next buttery lobster roll, you read David Foster Wallace's essay "Consider the Lobster". It was initially published in the now defunct Gourmet magazine, but you can read it in his essay collection Consider the Lobster. While Wallace won't tell you what to do w/r/t eating lobster, he does make a convincing case that boiling a creature that is sensible to changes in temperature of several degrees, must be an extreme form of torture that no amount of buttery goodness can mask. I had not eaten lobster for about a decade, but thought that I could not forgo such a distinctly New England dish. Wallace makes a point of noting how easy it is to shrug off moral qualms for the sake of good food. In a later article I would like to write about the possibility of eating well and without shrugs in New Haven. Stay tuned.)
The second fish food place I visited is also outdoors. It is called, appropriately enough, The Place. ( I think that giving fish shacks more sophisticated names would betray something essential to the fabric of the restaurant's genre.) Although both provide excellent food and are staffed by some of the friendliest people I've ever met in this state (The owners of the Place hang out at the restaurant and man the grill and will relate the history of the restaurant to you; the Lobster Shack seems to be more of a family operation, but the members of the family operate more felicitously in their two trailers filled with boiling pots and surrounded by customers than most families can manage over Thanksgiving), The Place has several advantages over The Lobster Shack. Although they are both outdoors, the former is surrounded by trees and has a canopy, which pacifies even a weather infant like myself. The menu is slightly larger, with about a dozen offering as opposed to about 5, so if you don't feel like lobster (which The Place doesn't have anyway) you could have grilled catfish, or a grilled steak, or grilled corn. Also, there is a lot of grilling going on with several attendants including the owner grappling with what seem to be perilous flames, which makes for a striking background to your meal. The rules are extremely lax in The Place: 1. Throw your clam shells on the ground.
2. Bring food that they do not sell but you think might go well with your grilled blackfish.
3. Bring your own alcohol. (I always feel cultured unwrapping a chilled bottle of wine at a restaurant.)
These rules are the perfect recipe for extended hanging out and feeling some control over the experience you have.
As for the actual food, I feel like it would be a disservice to actually work through describing the food here. You will have to trust me that it is all sufficiently delicious. These places are conscious of being fine, but not elaborate.